New: The Total Tax Intelligence Report — Know your case better than the IRS does. Learn More →
IRSMedic LogoIRSMedicWE AUDIT THE IRS

Crypto Losses: The Statute vs. the IRS Playbook

Much of what's called crypto tax law is IRS guidance, not the Internal Revenue Code. Here's which rules the statute supports, which the IRS wrote itself, and how to handle lost, stolen or abandoned crypto.

By Anthony Parent, Esq. Tax attorney, founder of IRSMedic

Published

AI assisted

From where I sit, I've concluded crypto has three core functions: you lose it, it gets stolen, or it gets taxed. Sometimes all three in one year.

And worse, for people who have been victims of theft, there could be an unwelcome tax bill. If you are looking for an alternative theory that could provide you some relief, you have come to the correct place.

The standard advice for investors who lost money goes like this: staking rewards are ordinary income when received, capital losses offset only $3,000 of ordinary income, unrealized losses don't count, and you can owe tax on money you no longer have. Some of that is the Internal Revenue Code. And some of it is the IRS just making it up.

This article separates the two, using only the statute and Supreme Court cases at hand. No notices, revenue rulings or Tax Court memos are given any weight, for reasons I explain below.

If you're an investor who feels embarrassed about the losses: don't. The rules were written badly, and much of what you've been told is IRS position, not law. If you're a tax pro: this is the map for knowing which positions you can push and how to file them openly.

What's actually law

The "crypto tax law" most people cite is IRS Notice 2014-21, plus Rev. Rul. 2019-24 (airdrops and hard forks) and Rev. Rul. 2023-14 (staking). None of these went through notice-and-comment rulemaking, and none bind a taxpayer. They're the IRS's litigating position. That is, all we know is how the IRS will answer a lawsuit.

After Loper Bright Enterprises v. Raimondo (2024), courts decide what a statute means for themselves. They don't defer to the agency, and subregulatory guidance never got deference in the first place.

So the test for any crypto rule is simple: can you point to the Code section or Supreme Court case that produces it?

Congress has touched crypto only at the edges. Few bills passed until the 2021 infrastructure law added a "digital asset" definition for broker reporting in §6045(g)(3)(D). No bill has yet passed deferring staking tax, extending wash-sale rules to crypto or adding a de minimis exemption, though House Ways and Means advanced a package in September 2026 (see PwC: Ways and Means advances digital asset tax legislation).

Where the statute backs the IRS

Actual Code sections do support it. These rules hold up without any notice:

Crypto rules the Internal Revenue Code supports

Rule

Where it comes from

Crypto received for services is income at fair market value

§61(a)(1) ("compensation for services"); §83 (property received for services)

Crypto-to-crypto trades are taxable

§1001 ("sale or other disposition"); Cottage Savings Ass'n v. Commissioner (1991): exchange of materially different property is realization; §1031 covers only real property since 2018

Capital losses offset only $3,000 of ordinary income a year

§1211(b); excess carries forward under §1212(b)

Unrealized losses aren't deductible

§165(a) allows losses "sustained"; §1001 requires a sale or other disposition

Crypto is generally a capital asset

§1221: "property held by the taxpayer" unless an exception applies

Where the IRS wrote the law

The "you owe tax on money you lost" story mostly comes from one IRS timing rule: newly created tokens are income the moment they land in your wallet. No Code section says that.

Staking and mining rewards

Rev. Rul. 2023-14 taxes staking rewards on receipt. The hypothesis against it, built only on Supreme Court law:

  • Eisner v. Macomber (1920) defined income as gain "severed" from capital. A pro rata stock dividend wasn't income because the holder's proportionate interest didn't change. Protocol issuance to stakers works much the same way.
  • Commissioner v. Glenshaw Glass Co. (1955), the IRS's favorite case, still requires gains that are "clearly realized."
  • Moore v. United States (2024) left the constitutional realization question open, while upholding what I call "vicarious realization": the Moores were taxed on earnings that belonged to KisanKraft, a separate Indian corporation, and were never distributed to them. It wasn't their money unless a dividend was declared. As 13% minority owners, they couldn't control KisanKraft or force a distribution. Its CFC status came from other shareholders.
  • The self-created property analogy: a farmer isn't taxed when the crop grows, only when it's sold.

The IRS's best answer: rewards go only to people who stake, so this isn't a pro rata dividend, and custodial rewards you can sell anytime look like cash. In Paschall, T.C. Memo. 2026-46, the Tax Court sided with the IRS on custodial (eToro) staking. But that's a memo opinion from an Article I court, not precedent by its own claim. The case actually looks more like a trial balloon for a potential Loper Bright workaround. (I don't think it works.) Validators who produce their own blocks have the stronger facts, and the Jarrett refund suit (M.D. Tenn.) is testing them in an Article III court.

Airdrops and hard forks

Rev. Rul. 2019-24 taxes them on receipt. You performed no service, received nothing from a payer, and after a chain split your proportionate interest is unchanged. That's the Macomber fact pattern again.

Valuation

For thin or illiquid tokens, Burnet v. Logan (1931) supports leaving the transaction open when value can't be ascertained, rather than assigning one.

The loss playbook: lost, stolen or abandoned

How the loss happened decides what the statute lets you do with it.

How each kind of crypto loss is treated under the statute

What happened

Statutory treatment

Status

Sold at a loss

Capital loss (§1001, §1211); offsets all capital gains, then $3,000 of ordinary income, rest carried forward

Settled

Sold and bought back right away

§1091 wash-sale rule covers "stock or securities," not crypto, so the loss is allowed

Statute today; pending bill would change it

Stolen in a scam or exchange collapse, in a profit-seeking transaction

§165(c)(2) theft loss, deductible in the year discovered (§165(e)); §67(b)(3) keeps it out of the disallowed miscellaneous deductions

Strong; facts must show theft and a profit motive

Abandoned or worthless, no sale

§165(c)(2) loss, but for a non-trader it's a miscellaneous itemized deduction under §67, which §67(g) disallows

Statute favors the IRS here; selling for $1 first creates a capital loss instead

Active trader

§475(f)(2) mark-to-market election for actively traded commodities turns losses ordinary and skips the $3,000 cap

Open hypothesis: whether crypto is a "commodity" under §475(e)(2) is untested

The practical lesson: a sale beats an abandonment, a documented theft beats both, and harvesting losses without a wash-sale rule is available while the statute stays as written.

The penalty question: what is a "rule"?

You may have noticed my quotes around "rule." These quotes reveal quite an interesting story of bootstrapped authority.

The IRS's real leverage isn't the tax on this. It's the 20% penalty in 26 U.S.C. 6662 (subsection (b)(1)) for "negligence or disregard of rules or regulations."

But here we go:

"Rule" is undefined. Title 26 never defines it. §7701 doesn't, and neither does §6662. The APA's broad definition in 5 U.S.C. §551(4) applies, by its own terms, only "for the purpose of this subchapter." The Code's own usage points narrow: §7805(a) has the Secretary "prescribe" rules and regulations, and §6110(b)(1) calls IRS guidance a "ruling," a different word.

Treasury filled the gap itself. Treas. Reg. §1.6662-3 (paragraph (b)(2)) says "rules or regulations" includes revenue rulings and notices. That definition arrived with the 1991 final regulations (T.D. 8381) and drew objections at the time that it exceeded IRS authority (see NYSBA Tax Section Report #698). The result: guidance that binds no one becomes something you're penalized for ignoring.

After Loper Bright, that's a very live issue. A court now reads "rules" for itself. Bittner v. United States (2023) read a penalty statute narrowly, and a plurality invoked the rule of lenity. The realistic argument isn't that "rule" is meaningless; it's that its best reading is things the Secretary prescribes with the force of law, not revenue rulings and notices.

Then there's the dilemma for the IRS. If a notice is a legislative rule, it needed notice and comment, and Mann Construction v. United States (6th Cir. 2022) struck down an IRS notice for skipping it. If it's an interpretive rule, Perez v. Mortgage Bankers Ass'n (2015) says it lacks "the force and effect of law." Either way, penalizing disregard of it is hard to defend.

Even regulations carry an internal contradiction. A regulation gets no deference in court, yet the regulations require you to disclose a position contrary to one on Form 8275-R and frame it as a good-faith challenge. The disclosure requirement itself is a regulation, not a statute; §6662(d)(2)(B) only asks that the facts be "adequately disclosed."

Worked example: $50,000 of rewards, sold for $5,000

The two readings produce a $42,000 swing in taxable income in year one. An investor earns $50,000 of staking rewards (value at receipt) in one year, then sells the tokens for $5,000 the same year and has no other capital gains.

$50,000 of staking rewards sold for $5,000, under each reading


IRS's contested reading (Rev. Rul. 2023-14)

Statute plus Supreme Court reading

Income when rewards arrive

$50,000 ordinary

$0 (no realization)

Basis in the tokens

$50,000

$0

Result on the $5,000 sale

$45,000 capital loss

$5,000 capital gain

Net taxable in year one

$47,000 ($50,000 minus $3,000 of loss)

$5,000

Left over

$42,000 loss carried forward at $3,000 a year: 14 more years with no gains

Nothing

Economically, the investor ended up with $5,000. Only one of these readings taxes them on that.

What to do now

For tax pros

  • Reconsider if any of your clients are entitled to relief from the IRS's self-created "rules" on crypto taxation. We have filed amended returns with more client-favorable positions.
  • Form 8275 disclosure could be optional, not a requirement. The statute asks only that facts be "adequately disclosed," and the form rule is itself a regulation open to the same challenge. Use it when a client wants belt-and-suspenders protection.

For investors

  • Losing money on crypto is very common, not shameful. The rules are confusing because much of what's called law is IRS guidance, and believe it or not, this government is intentionally confusing.
  • Don't abandon tokens. Sell them, even for pennies, and keep records of every reward, trade and theft.
  • Before you pay tax on rewards you never cashed, have someone check whether that tax comes from the Code or from an IRS ruling.

This article is general information, not legal advice for your situation.

On this page

Become a client

Know where you stand before the IRS does.

Tell us about your case in a short survey. We will point you to the right level of Tax Intelligence, and you can always go deeper later.